Family Law Appeals​

​

If you've received a decision from a trial court in a family law case and feel that the ruling was unjust or incorrect, it's crucial to consult with an appellate lawyer to understand your options moving forward. Family court rulings can significantly affect your life and the well-being of your family. If you disagree with the decision and believe you have grounds to appeal, an appellate lawyer can guide you through the process.

​

It's important to note that most people only have one opportunity to appeal. Therefore, it is essential to approach it correctly. Hiring an experienced appellate lawyer is a smart move, as they specialize in the nuances of appellate practice, are well-versed in the roles of appellate courts, and excel in legal research, writing, and oral advocacy.

​​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Understanding the Complexities of Family Law Appeals: Custody, Support, and Property Division

​

Family law appeals often hinge on specific facts and can involve matters like custody, visitation, support, or property division. Because appellate courts typically defer to the trial court's findings of fact, identifying viable grounds for an appeal can be challenging. When considering an appeal in a family law case, potential issues include whether the trial judge misinterpreted the evidence or failed to properly consider key details, whether there was a misapplication of a legal standard, such as the best interests of the child, or if the trial lacked procedural fairness. Another important issue is whether the judge’s reasons clearly and adequately explain their decision-making process.

​

Given the complexity and fact-specific nature of family law appeals, an appellate lawyer must thoroughly review the evidence and pinpoint a few strong arguments for a successful appeal. This requires experience, precision, and objectivity.

​

​

 

Deciding to Appeal a Family Court Decision: Know Your Options

​

In family court, you may not have had a choice about attending at the trial level, whether you were initiating the case or responding to one. However, if you're dissatisfied with the trial's outcome—whether you didn't receive everything you sought or because the other party was granted more than you believe was fair—you may have the option to appeal to a higher court, provided you are not responding to an appeal initiated by the other party.

The strategy for a successful appeal differs significantly from a trial strategy. While trials are heavily fact-based, appeals focus on the application and interpretation of the law. When considering whether to appeal, think about:

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Important Considerations Before Pursuing a Family Law Appeal

​

Before deciding to file a family law appeal, it is essential to assess the significance of the trial judgment's impact on your family. A substantial impact, such as losing custody of your children, might justify the costs of an appeal, whereas minor financial changes, like a small increase in spousal support, might not warrant the expense. The duration of the negative impact should also be considered. Final orders are generally more important to appeal than temporary ones because they represent the end of a case, while temporary orders may be subject to future changes.

Another factor to consider is whether waiting for a change in circumstances could be a better strategy. If you believe your situation could improve over time, such as being in a stronger position to care for your children, it might be more beneficial to request a modification later rather than filing an immediate appeal. However, motions based on changed circumstances can take longer and be more costly than appeals, so it's important to carefully weigh this decision.

​

The likelihood of success on appeal is also a crucial factor. It’s important to evaluate the fairness of the trial court's decision and consider how an impartial observer might view it. Appellate courts are generally reluctant to overturn a trial court’s findings of fact unless there is a clear and substantial error. Your chances of success are higher if there is a demonstrable legal mistake or if the trial court’s decision appears profoundly unjust.

 

 

 

 

Navigating the Appeals Process in Ontario Family Law

​

Appealing a family law order in Ontario can be complex, with different appeal routes depending on the court that made the original order. It’s important to determine whether your appeal should go to the Ontario Court of Appeal or the Divisional Court, and consulting with a lawyer can help you navigate these complexities. Understanding the different pathways for family law appeals in Ontario is essential for making informed decisions about your case.

4o

​

Appeals in Ontario can follow different paths based on the court of the original order. You might be appealing an order from the Ontario Court of Justice (OCJ) or the Superior Court of Justice (SCJ). Appeals from the OCJ go to a single judge of the SCJ, while SCJ appeals often go to the Ontario Divisional Court. Sometimes, the appeal may go directly to the Ontario Court of Appeal. Knowing the correct route is essential.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Know Your Rights: Appealing Family Law Orders at Different Courts

​

Appealing a family law order requires understanding the rights associated with different courts. From the OCJ, you have an automatic right to appeal an interim order to a single SCJ judge, but strict deadlines apply. In contrast, appeals from the SCJ often require “leave to appeal,” which isn’t guaranteed. Appeals for final orders from either court do not require special permission, but deadlines must be adhered to carefully.

 

 

 

 

What Can Be Appealed? Understanding the Limits of Family Law Appeals

​

Contrary to popular belief, an appeal is not a retrial and isn't meant to rehash evidence or arguments. Instead, it's a review of whether legal errors were made during the original judgment. Successful appeals focus on significant legal misjudgments rather than factual disagreements. The appellate court generally seeks to correct clear legal errors or miscarriages of justice, not re-evaluate witness credibility or minor factual discrepancies.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Important Tips for a Successful Family Law Appeal

​

Timing and process are critical in appeals. Missing the stringent deadlines can mean losing the opportunity to challenge a trial court’s decision. You need to be aware of deadlines for serving and filing notices of appeal and accompanying documents. Crafting a strong Notice of Appeal with well-defined grounds is essential for grabbing the court's attention and increasing your chances of success.

​

 

 

 

How Our Firm Evaluates Whether to Proceed with a Family Law Appeal

​

When considering an appeal, our firm requires some basic documents to review the case's merits, including the judge’s written decision and any relevant court records or orders. We conduct a preliminary assessment to provide an initial opinion on the case's potential for appeal. If an appeal seems viable, we offer a detailed consultation to discuss the next steps and associated costs.

​

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Why Hiring an Experienced Ontario Family Lawyer is Essential for Your Appeal

​

If you’re considering appealing a family law order in Ontario, it's best to consult with a skilled appellate lawyer to evaluate your case's merits and guide you through the next steps. Contact us today for an initial consultation and to decide the best course of action for your situation.

​​​​​

In Ontario, the family law appeal process is governed by strict deadlines, making it crucial for those considering an appeal to be aware of and adhere to these timelines. Missing a deadline can result in losing the right to appeal, so understanding the specific timeframes for filing appeals is essential.

​

1. Final Orders: If you are appealing a final order in a family law case, such as a divorce decree or a final custody decision, the deadline to file a Notice of Appeal is typically 30 days from the date the order was made. This means you must serve and file your Notice of Appeal with the court within this 30-day period. The Notice of Appeal must also be served on the other party involved in the case within the same timeframe.

2. Interim or Temporary Orders: Appeals involving interim or temporary orders, such as those related to temporary custody or support, have different deadlines and requirements. In some cases, you may need to seek "leave to appeal," which means you must first obtain permission from the court to proceed with your appeal. The deadline to apply for leave to appeal an interim order is often shorter, sometimes as brief as 7 days from the date the order was made. It is important to consult the specific rules of the court where your case was heard to confirm the exact deadline.

3. Child Protection Orders: Appeals related to child protection cases have even more stringent deadlines due to the urgent nature of these matters. The timeframes can vary, but they are generally much shorter than those for other types of family law appeals. It is crucial to act quickly and consult a lawyer immediately if you are considering an appeal in a child protection case. In addition to these general deadlines, there are several procedural steps and timelines that must be followed throughout the appeal process. These may include deadlines for filing the appeal record, factum (a written argument), and any additional supporting documents. Failure to meet these deadlines can result in the dismissal of the appeal or other penalties.

​

Given the complexity and strict nature of these deadlines, it is highly recommended to seek legal advice from an appellate lawyer who specializes in family law appeals. An experienced lawyer can help ensure that all deadlines are met and that the appeal is properly prepared and filed according to the rules of the court.

​

Understanding and adhering to these deadlines is critical in preserving your right to appeal and in presenting a compelling case to the appellate court.